FlowzObserver
Payments Regulation

Payments Regulation: States Press On With Interchange Relief Bills

More than 30 interchange bills were filed in state legislatures this year while Illinois's swipe-fee law goes to the Seventh Circuit, with argument set Jan. 27.

Nov 10, 20263 min read

A liquor store owner told a New York lawmaker that he was being charged a card fee for collecting the state’s sales tax. That complaint, repeated by merchants in statehouses across the country, explains why interchange bills keep arriving even as the best-known one, Illinois’s Interchange Fee Prohibition Act, sits in federal court. Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and New Jersey have pending bills that could pass before their sessions end, weeks before the Illinois appeal is argued.

The bills in play

Each of the three proposals would exempt sales tax from interchange fees, and two would also exempt gratuities. Interchange is the fee card-issuing banks charge merchants on each credit card payment, separate from other network and intermediary charges.

In New Jersey, Senate bill 4360 bars card networks from charging interchange on sales tax or tips as long as the merchant transmits those amounts in the authorization or settlement data. It also forbids raising rates on the rest of the transaction to make up the lost revenue. It sits in the Senate Commerce Committee, with a companion Assembly bill, A5014, referred to the Financial Institutions and Insurance Committee. The legislature is scheduled to adjourn December 17.

Massachusetts Senate bill 688 follows the same approach, and the bill was designated for further study in July, with results expected before year-end. The session ends January 5, 2027, and no House companion exists. In Pennsylvania, House bill 2090 would require networks to deduct sales tax from interchange calculations or rebate the fee, and bars workarounds such as raising other fees or penalizing merchants for pricing in compliance with the law. Its Senate companion is SB 1202, and the legislature is scheduled to adjourn November 30. All three call for monetary penalties.

The Electronic Transactions Association counts 32 interchange-related bills introduced in 20 states, Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico in 2026, and 75 since 2025 across 32 states, D.C. and Puerto Rico. Most target sales tax and tips.

The Illinois case sets the terms

The Illinois act has been delayed to July 1, 2027, to let legal challenges play out. In June, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency issued an order that the National Bank Act preempts Illinois from regulating interchange for national banks and federal savings associations. A federal judge in the Northern District of Illinois then issued a permanent injunction exempting those institutions, which leaves state-chartered banks and credit unions subject to the law.

The Illinois Bankers Association and other plaintiffs have appealed to get relief for state-chartered institutions as well, with a brief due December 21. The Illinois attorney general’s office appealed in October to have the injunction overturned and the law upheld as passed, with a brief due November 23 and a reply to the plaintiffs’ brief due January 11, 2027. Oral arguments before the Seventh Circuit are set for January 27, 2027.

Lawmakers face an odd sequencing problem: the legal test for their bills is being argued in January, but their sessions end before then.

Scott Talbott of the ETA warned that passing a similar bill before the appeal is settled invites a lawsuit, since the Illinois challenge has set a precedent. Doug Kantor, general counsel for the National Association of Convenience Stores, said bills will likely be written to avoid problems courts find in the Illinois law, and suggested merchants could challenge the OCC’s preemption ruling directly.

Two sides, one fee

Sponsors argue that sales tax and tips are not merchant revenue, so charging interchange on them is unreasonable. New York Assemblyman John McDonald, a pharmacist who introduced a similar bill last year and was re-elected last week, said interchange on tax and gratuities can reach $1,000 a month or more for small businesses.

Ashley Sharp of the Illinois Credit Union League replied that exempting those portions shifts costs rather than eliminating them. She said interchange helps fund secure payment infrastructure, fraud prevention and consumer protections. The Illinois Bankers Association’s general counsel said the group is pursuing every legal avenue to protect the whole banking industry.

What to watch

The first signal comes before the holidays: whether New Jersey or Pennsylvania passes a bill by their adjournment dates. If either does, the ETA has said a lawsuit is likely. The Seventh Circuit arguments on January 27 will then shape how much room state legislators have to try again in 2027.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related